Buy Your Watch - Premium Watch Buyers Australia

Reviews

Buy Your Watch reviews, and how to check them

Every rating and every quote on this page comes from our Google Business listing. We did not write them, we cannot edit them, and each reviewer's name links to their own Google profile so you can see the person behind the words.

4.9out of 5

76 Google reviews

Snapshot taken 17 November 2026

Open the Google listing

In their words

The reviews Google returns

Google's API hands back at most five reviews for a listing, sorted by most relevant. These are those five, unedited, spelling and punctuation included. Every one of them is a five-star review, because that is what Google returned. The average across the whole listing is 4.9, so not every review on it is.

  • 4 November 2026
    So, I had made an appointment to see the other Vintage Watch guys in Sydney to sell my Rolex, travelled three hours in to my appointment, they balked and mumbled and totally went back on their word. Buy My watch gave a firm offer based on photos before inspection, the money was in my account before I left the Horologist’ store. The whole experience was efficient and sublime, and I got a great price for my timepiece. I don’t do reviews, but James is remarkably courteous and helpful, I cannot recommend them highly enough. Thank you very much.
    gra 724Google review · a week ago
  • 7 November 2026
    Great experience selling my watch to Buy Your Watch. The whole process was quick, easy and straightforward from start to finish. James was very helpful, transparent and professional throughout, which made the transaction stress free. Everything was handled smoothly and I’d happily recommend them to anyone looking to sell their watch.
    An d NGoogle review · a week ago
  • 6 November 2026
    I dealt with James. His communication was clear and also friendly. He was happy yo work with me towards a mutually beneficial deal. I would have no hesitation in recommending this company. I took my watch into Melbourne for verification and gor the agreed paym3nt instantly once verified. Instant and without hiccups. Thanks James
    Pete BainGoogle review · a week ago
  • 5 November 2026
    Had a great experience dealing with James. Sold him a watch and the entire process was smooth, straightforward and hassle-free. Great communication, genuine bloke and a pleasure to deal with. Would happily recommend James to anyone looking to sell their watch. Thanks again, mate!
    Ricky Little (Real Estate)Google review · a week ago
  • 9 November 2026
    Selling my Rolex to James at Buy Your Watch was an absolute pleasure. The entire process was exceptionally easy, straightforward, and by far the best experience I’ve had. Highly recommend dealing with James!
    Joe MiskovicGoogle review · a week ago

The other 71 reviews are on the listing. Read all 76 on Google.

Small print

What this page is, and what it is not

Reviews are the easiest thing on a website to stage, so it is worth being exact about where these came from and what they can and cannot tell you.

  • The reviews belong to Google, not to us

    They sit on our Google Business listing. We cannot write one, edit one, delete one or change the order they come back in. Each name above links to that reviewer's own Google profile, so you can confirm an account with its own history left it.

  • Five is a ceiling, not a shortlist

    Google's Places API returns at most five reviews for a listing and offers no way to page through the rest, so five is what this page can show automatically. The rest are on the listing, one click away. Transcribing them onto this page by hand would make us the editor of our own reviews, which is the thing worth avoiding.

  • The figures here are a snapshot

    The rating and the review count were read from Google on 17 November 2026 and committed to the site, so they are in this page's HTML rather than appearing after it loads. The cost of that is real: they move only when we refresh them. The Google listing carries today's number.

  • Nothing on this page is a testimonial we wrote

    Every quote here came back from Google's API for our listing, and every name links to the reviewer's own Google profile. We did not write, select or edit any of them. If a quote cannot be opened on Google, it is not on this page.

Checkable

Three things you can verify without asking us

None of these depend on this website being truthful. Each one is held by someone other than us.

  • Registered entity

    BUY YOUR WATCH PTY LTD, ACN 670 502 315, ABN 85 670 502 315, active from 14 August 2023.

    View on ABN Lookup
  • Licence

    Second-Hand Dealer and Pawnbroker Licence No. SHD-0017882, issued in Victoria under the Second-Hand Dealers and Pawnbrokers Act 1989 (Vic). It is the licence the lending service operates under.

    Consumer Affairs Victoria
  • Google listing

    4.9 out of 5 from 76 reviews as at 17 November 2026, hosted by Google and not by us.

    Open on Google Maps

Questions

Questions about our reviews

If the answer to one of these is not checkable somewhere other than this website, it is not much of an answer.

Is Buy Your Watch a legitimate business?

Yes, and you do not have to take our word for it. The registered entity is BUY YOUR WATCH PTY LTD, ACN 670 502 315, ABN 85 670 502 315, active from 14 August 2023 and viewable on the public ABN Lookup register. We also hold Second-Hand Dealer and Pawnbroker Licence No. SHD-0017882, issued in Victoria, which is the licence the lending side of the business operates under, and Consumer Affairs Victoria maintains a public register of licensees.

How can I check these reviews are genuine?

Two ways, both of them off this website. Every reviewer's name links to their public Google contributor profile, so you can see the account and what else it has reviewed. The rating links to our Google Business listing, where the reviews are hosted. The figures shown here are 4.9 out of 5 from 76 Google reviews as at 17 November 2026, and the listing carries the live number.

Do you pay for reviews, or remove the bad ones?

No to the first, and we could not do the second even if we wanted to. The reviews are hosted by Google on its own listing, not on our servers, so they are not ours to edit, delete or reorder. Our average is not a perfect five, and the listing is where you will find the reviews that are not five stars.

Who are James, Andy, Danny and Max in the reviews?

They are the people those customers dealt with. We do not publish job titles, biographies or credentials for anyone here, because a title on our own website is not something a reader can check. Max Summers is the owner of the business and writes the guides on this site.

Get Started

Find out what yours is worth

A free valuation, free authentication by a certified watchmaker, and no obligation to sell afterwards. If the numbers do not suit you, we will tell you that too.